Fire Island isn't just famous for its beaches—it's also a hidden gem for food lovers. Whether you're planning a beach day or a weekend getaway, these top restaurants offer the perfect bite with a view:
1. The Island Mermaid – Ocean Beach
This waterfront spot is a Fire Island staple. Enjoy fresh seafood, live music, and sunset cocktails on the deck. Try the lobster roll or Mermaid Platter—locals swear by it.
2. Matthew’s Seafood House – Ocean Beach
A cozy, casual spot known for its fried clams, seafood bisque, and laid-back beach-town vibe. Great for families!
3. Maguire’s Bayfront Restaurant – Ocean Beach
A classic seafood and steakhouse with stunning bay views. Their brunch and crab cakes are top-tier.
4. Castaway Bar & Grill – Ocean Beach
Chill, beachy atmosphere with great pub fare, frozen drinks, and a lively crowd. Their tacos and burgers are must-tries.
5. CJ’s – “Home of the Rocket Fuel”
You can’t go to Fire Island without trying a Rocket Fuel from CJ’s. Known for this signature frozen cocktail, CJ’s also serves up solid American fare and a fun scene.
Whether you're a foodie or just hungry after a beach day, Fire Island's dining scene never disappoints.
📞 Ready to find your dream home near all this? Call The Galluzzo Team at 631-774-3333 today.
